Community

Restorative Justice – My Conversation with ChatGPT

Written by Samuel Phillips

In the article: The Role of Identity in Restorative Justice, I mentioned sharing the article with ChatGPT, and a conversation ensued.

ChatGPT responded with this statement:

Your proposal raises an interesting distinction between the state imposing punishment and an individual voluntarily accepting responsibility under agreed conditions. I have preserved that distinction as you presented it. The idea of signing away the right to a subsequent trial, however, raises important questions about due process, consent, and the protection of individual rights. These could be explored in a later section without weakening the central philosophical argument you are developing.

I responded by saying:

“The idea of signing away the right to a subsequent trial, however, raises important questions about due process, consent and the protection of individual rights.” This is a fair statement, but it’s actually what the argument is meant to create: a system where people think about the fact that they have signed their own law by an oath, as a deterrent to committing crime. The protection of individual rights should not be an excuse for infringing on the rights of others in the community. Therefore, the argument is not about what is a rightful justice after a crime has been committed, but that there should not be crime in the first place if people know themselves based on their purpose and identity. Or do you not agree?

ChatGPT responded and says:

I agree with the philosophical foundation of your argument, and I think your clarification brings out something that I did not fully appreciate in my earlier editorial observation.

You are not primarily proposing a different way of punishing people after they commit crimes. You are proposing a system that makes people more conscious of their responsibility to the community before they commit crimes.

There is an important distinction here.

  1. Moving justice from punishment to prevention

Most modern justice systems become involved after someone has violated the rights of another person. The process then focuses on establishing guilt, determining the appropriate punishment, and enforcing the sentence.

Your argument is asking a more fundamental question:

What if justice began with helping people understand who they are, what their purpose is, and what their responsibilities are to the people with whom they share a community?

In that sense, the Himba story becomes particularly relevant. The song is a reminder that a person’s identity is greater than their wrongdoing. The community does not simply respond to the offence; it attempts to reconnect the individual with the person they are supposed to be.

Your proposal takes this idea further by introducing personal accountability through an oath.

  1. Individual rights and collective responsibility

I also agree with your point that the protection of individual rights should not become an excuse for disregarding the rights of others.

Individual liberty and collective responsibility should not be opposing principles. My freedom cannot legitimately become a licence to violate someone else’s freedom.

However, I would make one distinction: protecting the rights of an accused person is not necessarily protecting wrongdoing. It is also about ensuring that the state does not mistakenly punish an innocent person or exercise arbitrary power.

This is where I would slightly refine your argument.

The oath should create a heightened sense of personal responsibility, but it should not remove the obligation to establish guilt through a fair process. Otherwise, an individual could be punished for an accusation rather than a proven offence.

The state can remain an enforcer without becoming an unquestionable authority over the individual’s rights.

  1. The deeper idea behind your proposal

I think the most interesting aspect of your argument is that you are questioning the assumption that human beings need the threat of punishment to behave responsibly.

What if people were instead taught to understand their identity, their place in society, and the consequences of their actions on other human beings?

What if the law was not merely something imposed on people by an external authority, but something they consciously understood, accepted, and took responsibility for upholding?

Your Bakare example is an attempt to explore precisely that possibility.

There is, however, one philosophical distinction worth retaining: knowing one’s identity and purpose may reduce the inclination to commit wrongdoing, but it cannot guarantee that nobody will commit a crime. Human behaviour is influenced by many things, including circumstances, conflicting interests and deliberate choices. That does not invalidate your proposal; it simply means prevention and accountability must work together.

  1. What I think your article is really arguing

I would express the central argument this way:

Justice should not begin with the question of what to do with people who have committed crimes. It should begin with the question of how to build a society in which people understand themselves, recognise the humanity of others, and take responsibility for preserving the balance of their communities.

This is a much deeper argument than simply advocating shorter prison sentences or alternative forms of punishment.

And I would suggest one important addition to your article: distinguish between the law as an instrument of control and the law as an expression of collective responsibility.

Your argument appears to be that laws should not merely exist to frighten people into obedience. They should help people understand the responsibility that comes with living among other human beings.

I find that a worthwhile philosophical argument to develop.

One question I would leave at the heart of your article is this:

If we spend so much time, money and energy building systems to punish people after they have done wrong, why don’t we invest the same energy in building societies that help people understand why doing wrong to another human being is, in the first place, a departure from the very humanity we all share?

That, to me, is the strongest thread connecting Burkina Faso, the Himba story, your proposal about Bakare, and the broader question of restorative justice.”

What do you think?

Looks like quite a good debate with ChatGPT, but I also think the various strands of the arguments are worth looking into, even as we keep the work of restorative justice going. There is no one single answer to crime in our world, and no one single system that helps with that reality.

Nevertheless, you can share your thoughts in the comment section below.

About the author

Samuel Phillips

Leave a Comment